European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, Vol 11, 676-681, Copyright © 1997 by European Association for Cardio-thoracic Surgery
Are pulmonary homografts subjected to pulmonary hypertension more appropriate for aortic valve replacement than normal pulmonary homografts? Results of echocardiography in a multicentric study
M Gaudino, T Van Geldorp, W Daenen, P Kalmar and Y Goffin
European Homograft Bank, Brussels, Belgium.
OBJECTIVE: To compare the function in aortic position of cryopreserved
pulmonary homografts subjected to pulmonary hypertension with that of
normal cryopreserved pulmonary homografts. METHODS: Pulmonary valves (52)
were implanted in aortic position in different cardiothoracic centres. The
valves were classified as follows: Group I-pulmonary hypertension (procured
from recipients of heart/heart-lung transplantation, 31 valves), Group
II-normal pulmonary pressure (procured from cadavers and multiorgan donors,
21 valves). Regular echocardiographic follow-up was obtained by the
implanting centers. Significant echo changes were defined as insufficiency
> 2+ and/or stenosis producing a delta P > 30 mm Hg. RESULTS:
Pulmonary homografts showed the following significant echo changes: in the
Pulmonary Hypertension Group, 7, 27 and 33% at 12, 24 and 36 months,
respectively; in the normal PA Group 10, 37.5 and 80% at 12, 24 and 36
months, respectively. In both groups the most common echocardiographic
alteration was homograft insufficiency rather than stenosis. Thus,
pulmonary homografts subjected to long-term pulmonary hypertension have
significantly less echo changes than normal pulmonary homografts,
especially after 12 months (chi 2: P < 0.036). CONCLUSIONS: These
findings suggest that pulmonary valves subjected to pulmonary hypertension
might be more appropriate than normal pulmonary homograft for aortic valve
replacement, constituting a possible alternative in case of lack of aortic
valve homografts. However, the failure of two out of five valves in the
longer term must dictate caution while waiting further long-term results.