|
|
||||||||
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 1998;14:584-589
© 1998 Elsevier Science NL
University Hospital, Department of Cardio-Vascular Surgery, B.P.426, F. 67091 Strasbourg, France
Received 28 September 1998; accepted 6 October 1998.
Corresponding author. Tel.: +33-3-8811-6243; fax: +33-3-8811-6342.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: Cardiac surgery Mitral insufficiency Mitral valve repair Surgical technique Ring
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A number of devices have been designed to meet the aformentioned requirements, either by a rigid ring or by a partially or fully flexible device to maintain annulus flexibility and motion. However, there is a number of mitral regurgitations where there is only minimal or trivial annulus dilatation. This is the case in many patients with isolated prolapse of the posterior leaflet (IPPL) as is seen in myxomatous degeneration. As the defect accounting for the insufficiency appeared very localized, we assumed there is no need for a ring to be used, once the responsible defect is cured and leaflet coaptation restored. This report analyses the long-term follow-up of this series in order to support the assumption.
| Material and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The repair consisted in resection of the flail portion of the prolapsed valve, and plication of the posterior annulus. They represent nearly 40% of all patients submitted to repair. All those who required implantation of a ring, leaflet transfer, chordal shortening, or neo chordae, were excluded. Patients with significant aortic valve involvement were also excluded from this series.
There were 70 males and 26 females. Mean age was 60.7±11.3 years ranging from 33 to 81 years, and 20 patients were 70 or older. Fifty-seven patients (60%) were in New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional 3 or 4 class; two were on mechanical ventilation at the time of operation. Sinus rhythm was recorded in 73 patients, 23 had arrhythmia. Mean ejection fraction was 63.6±9.4% with only eight patients having less than 50% ejection fraction. All underwent preoperative coronary angiography, 11 patients had ischemic coronary disease, eight underwent concomitant CABG. A small grade aortic insufficiency was present in 13 patients. Ten patients had a history of previous endocarditis, which was never active at time of operation. The repair consisted in the resection of the flail portion of the prolapsed valve, and plication of the posterior annulus.
In all patients an as simple as possible surgical procedure was carried out. It included quadrangular (in one case double quadrangular) resection of the prolapsed portion of the posterior leaflet, and plication (reinforced on pledgets) of the corresponding portion of the mural annulus. This technique was used in 27 patients. If there was a larger plication needed by the resection, (usually more than 15 mm of the extent of the annulus), sustained traction may be applied on the annular plication line and could result in suture dehiscence. Then the repair was reinforced by a localized annuloplasty obtained by suturing a small strip of tissue, (23 cm in length) through the annulus on both sides of the plication. The strip was cut out of a snare, most often from a Gore-Tex® vascular prosthesis. The posterior annuloplasty reinforcement technique was used in 69 patients.
In a few cases, marginal techniques were added (Table 1) as two cases of annular decalcification in order to allow the plication of the annulus after quadragular resection.
|
All patients were post-operatively given anticoagulation therapy with warfarine. Anticoagulants were given during the early years for 2 months and since 3 years they were given for up to 6 months, even in patients in sinus rhythm. Patients in atrial fibrillation were given anticoagulants indefinitely.
Data were obtained by in-hospital examinations of the patients or from those collected from their cardiologists. Functional and echocardiographic data were obtained in 81 patients. Regurgitation was graded from 0 to 4 by color-flow and pulsed-wave Doppler measurements. Grade 3 and 4 were accepted as significant regurgitation for considering reoperation.
Statistical Analysis
Patient characteristics are summarized with percentages for category data and with mean±standard deviation for continuous data. Due to the small samples in some subgroups, results were recalculated by Fischer's exact test. Multivariate analysis was assessed by logistic regression. Life time analysis of post-operative events such as death, thromboembolism,endocarditis, reoperations were calculated with the KaplanMeier's method. A probability value less than 0.05 was considered significant.
Factors assessed were: age>69-years old (n=20), NYHA functional class III and IV (n=57), LV ejection fraction <50% (n=8), concomitant ischemic heart disease (n=11), heart rhythm (arrhythmia n=23), type of posterior annuloplasty (without annular strip n=27). Univariate and multivariate analysis were used to determine their significance on early- and late-death and on all post-operative events taken as a whole.
The SOLO® statistical software package from BMDP was used for statistical computation.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The 30-day mortality was 1% (1 of 96 patients). This patient was a 72-year-old woman, who had been suffering for bilateral pulmonary edema for many weeks. She was operated on while on mechanical ventilation and on intra-aortic balloon counterpulsation. Despite a good mitral repair and excellent cardiac function, she died on the 30th post-operative day due to refractory pulmonary hypoxia.
There were four late deaths, at a mean duration of 6 years (0.910 years). They were due to: (i) myocardial failure in a 85-year-old woman, 10 years after mitral repair (ii) myocardial failure occuring 10 months after repair (iii) sudden death at 8 years (iv) malignancy by melanoma at 4 years.
Three deaths were valve-related, and myocardial failure was the main cause of death, especially if the sudden death is included in that category. No predictive factor of early or late death could be identified either by univariate or multivariate analysis, due to the small number of events. Therefore, all valve-related events (death, mitral insufficiency and thromboembolic episodes) were aggregated and plotted against the variables. No correlation could be found (Table 2).
|
There were eight thromboembolic and two hemorrhagic events. One patient sustained a transient ischemic attack (TIA) 2 months post-operatively. This patient had had reinforcement of the annulus plication by a string of Gore-Tex®. All but one were fully regressive. Two occured early (at 2 months post-op). The others occured later on, between the 1st and 5th post-operative years. Four patients were in sinus rhythm while six presented with arrhythmia.
No post-operative endocarditis was observed. There was neither hemolysis reported in this series, nor mitral stenosis, nor again left ventricular outflow tract obstruction.
Linearized rates of post-operative events were:0.9%/year for late mortality, 0.5%/year for late reoperation, 2.3%/year for late thromboembolic or hemorrhagic events, 0%/year for late endocarditis, 0.7%/year for late recurrent mitral insufficieny.
Survival
Overall actuarial survival was 95.5%±2.7 at 5 years and 90.5%±5.5 at 8 years (
Fig. 1
). The actuarial rate of recurrence-free from significant MR was 96.2±2.6% at 5 years and 92.6±4.3% at 8 years (
Fig. 2
), reoperation-free actuarial rate for reoperation on mitral valve was 97.8±2.1% at 5 years and 94.2±4.1% at 8 years.
Fig. 3
, event-free actuarial rate for thromboembolic or hemorrhagic events was 84.3±4.3% at 5 years and 72.3±11.9% at 8 years (
Fig. 4
), for endocarditis 100% at 5 years and later. Actuarial rate of event-free from any possible valve related complication was 80.5% at 5 years and 65.8% at 8 years.
|
|
|
|
| Comments |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Despite numerous studies, no significant improvement has been documented between the older rigid or the more recent flexible rings [13].The progressive loss of annular flexibility could be one of the suggested explanations, but until now has not yet been demonstrated. Flexibility is more long-lasting with some devices, and annular contraction could improve over time [13]. Therefore, the beneficial impact could be important only in patients with significant preoperative left ventricular dysfunction. According to the good results reported it may seem unnecessary to keep off a ring. However, these results are frequently based on mid-term studies and the possible drawbacks of a ring may only appear in a later phase.
In most of our mitral reoperations where a ring had been inserted during the first procedure (19 patients) one could clearly identify gross fibrosis and sometimes calcifications on the site of implantation; these changes overlapped significantly to the adjacent mitral leaflets. The precise role played by fibrosis in the ultimate failure of the primary repair has still to be defined, but it has a possible role.
Cerfolio [14] reports the recent experience of the Mayo Clinic with 49 reoperations after mitral valve repair. If there are some technical failures, in 32 patients the initial repair was intact and above all, there was fibrosis formation, thickening and calcifications involving the leaflets and in seven cases the annulus. In addition, the authors report that 41 patients showed on echocardiographic examination signs of (recurrent?) annular dilatation; and at least in some cases, it happened in the probable presence of a ring! Whether or not annulus involvment was determining, whether or not the primary aetiology was evolving cannot be established. It is also probable that the 2.7% reoperation rate may be higher, since not all of the 1500 patients with mitral repair were contacted. It seems, accordingly, that a ring may be detrimental in the long-term, and if there is not definite need for it, it might be discarded.
Our series consists only of the very special subset of patients presenting with myxomatous degeneration where the pathologic process is an isolated prolapse of the posterior leaflet. In those patients there is usually no obvious annular dilatation. Also leaflet coaptation appears generally satisfactory apart from the prolapsed section, and left ventricular function is also protected, though the patients may be in high grade functional class [13] [15] [16]. These patients are candidates for the very `simple operation'.
It may be stated in favor of the ring that in myxomatous degeneration the whole leaflet is sick, and if there is no gross dilatation of the annulus, such a dilatation may develop in the long run. Nevertheless, there is no difference in histological appearance of the annulus of myxomatous degeneration and that of a normal valve. In both cases, there is a frequent discontinuity of the annulus [17]. Though in isolated PPL as there is no other obvious cause of mitral regurgitation, no preventive action such as a mitral ring insertion can be taken and warrants the effects. The long-term results of the present series are in favor of this interpretation; it allows for a simplified operation. Cohn [18] found that in myxomatous degeneration patients receiving a ring are doing better than those without a ring. But his patients were often submitted to complex repair including techniques on the anterior leaflet and the chordae. Diffuse degeneration is a risk factor for late failure [15], possibly independent from the presence of a ring. Surprisingly in some cases of severe mitral dystrophy, it has been suggested not to insert a ring because of a tissue `being to fragile' [19]. Theoretically, these cases would have been the best indications of this procedure!
We stopped performing routine TEE after mitral repair. Although good results have been reported in patients with less than `echo-perfect' results after mitral repair [20], we are in favor of a quasi perfect repair to promote good long-term results. This may also account for the excellent long-term stability of this series after surgery and explain the lack of discrepancy between the intra-operative competence-test and the TEE during surgery. In other situations, TEE remains an invaluable tool. In a series of 309 patients [21], TEE could document intraoperatively 26 immediate failures (8%), ten incomplete corrections, ten left ventricular outflow tract obstructions (LVOTO), and six suture dehiscences which led to immediate surgical correction. We consider that in difficult or complex repairs including chordae shortening, leaflets transfers, and each time the repair appears unsatisfactory, performing a peroperative TEE remains mandatory.
Dehiscence of the ring does not occur rarely [14] [20]. If a ring is not required, it seems advisable to avoid implanting one. Occurence of LVOTO has raised much interest [22], and to some extent, remains an unclear situation, though it has been infrequently reported following the sliding technique, or in repairs without a ring [23]. In this series there was neither LVOTO nor hemolysis case [24].
One such patient presented with a TIA 2 months post-operatively. As the patient was in sinus rhythm, the reason may be clot formation on the intra-cardiac foreign material and embolization. Therefore, anticoagulation is now continued up to 6 months post-operatively, even in the presence of a sinus rhythm. It also raised the question played by intracardiac prosthetic material and that of the consistency of anticoagulation. In order to reduce the amount of foreign materiel and potential sites of thrombus formation, the strip has been discarded since February 1996 by a modification of the sliding technique [4]. The flail portion is resected, an appropriate incision along the remnants of the posterior leaflet on each side is made; and at each endpoint of the leaflet incision the annulus is plicated. By this way traction as well as the amount of foreign material is reduced. The posterior leaflet is easily reconstructed by continuous suture.
| Conclusion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
| Appendix A. Conference discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Dr Eisenmann: To tell you that the ring is not necessary in all undilated mitral annulus when you do repair, we try to use it in a special subset of patients. And in this subset of patients, we, at 10 years, had no deleterious effect of the absence of the ring. Maybe, that the ring is not necessary in other cases but I can't comment about that.
Dr A. Ashmeg (Jedda, Saudi Arabia): I think quite a few surgeons around the world do mitral valve repair with no ring. And one of them is actually Dr Yacoub in London, he's been using complex mitral repairs with no ring for many years. We have done 221 cases of mitral repair and in about 30% of them we used no ring, for mitral regurgitation. Recently we have done a redo for two cases who had complex mitral repair, 15 and 17 years ago. If those patients had rings put in at that time, it probably would have been very difficult to repeat a repair on them. Those two who I have put a ring on, it will probably unlikely that a third repair will be done in the future. But I think that is an important point. A patient who receives no ring has a chance of a re-repair in the long-term.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. Fundaro, P. M Tartara, E. Villa, P. Fratto, S. Campisi, and E. O Vitali Mitral Valve Repair: Is There Still a Place for Suture Annuloplasty? Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann, August 1, 2007; 15(4): 351 - 358. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. M. Calafiore, M. Di Mauro, A. L. Iaco, V. Mazzei, G. Teodori, S. Gallina, L. Weltert, M. Samoun, and G. Di Giammarco Overreduction of the Posterior Annulus in Surgical Treatment of Degenerative Mitral Regurgitation Ann. Thorac. Surg., April 1, 2006; 81(4): 1310 - 1316. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |