|
|
||||||||
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2001;20:496-501
© 2001 Elsevier Science NL
a Division of Thoracic Surgery, University Hospital of Berne, Berne, Switzerland
b Department of Surgery, University Hospital of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland
c Division of Pulmonary Medicine, University Hospital of Berne, Berne, Switzerland
Received 4 October 2000; received in revised form 19 May 2001; accepted 22 May 2001.
Corresponding author. Tel.: +41-21-314-2408; fax: +41-21-314-2358
e-mail: hris{at}chuv.hospvd.ch
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
4 ribs fractured at
2 sites) underwent surgical stabilisation using reconstruction plates. Clinical assessment and pulmonary function testing were performed at 6 months following surgery. Results: Fifty-five (83%) patients had various combinations of injuries of the thorax, head, abdomen and extremities. Sixty-three (95.5%) patients underwent unilateral and 3 (4.5%) patients bilateral stabilisation with a median delay of 2.8 days (range 021 days) from admission. The 30-day mortality was 11% (seven of 66 patients). Immediate postoperative extubation was feasible in 31 of 66 patients (47%) and extubation within 7 days following stabilisation in 56 of 66 patients (85%). No plate dislocation was observed during the follow-up. The shoulder girdle function was intact in 51 of 57 patients (90%). Chest wall complaints were noted in 6 of 57 (11%) patients, requiring removal of implants in three cases. All patients returned to work within a mean period of 8 (range 316) weeks following discharge. Pulmonary function testing (n=50) at 6 months after the operation revealed a significant difference of predicted vs. recorded vital capacity (VC) and forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1) (P=0.04 and P=0.0001, respectively; Wilcoxon signed-rank test). The median ratio of the recorded and predicted total lung capacity (TLC) was shown to be significantly higher than 0.85 (P=0.0002; Wilcoxon signed-rank test), indicating prevention of pulmonary restriction. Conclusion: Antero-lateral flail chest injuries accompanied by respiratory insufficiency can be effectively stabilised using reconstruction plates. Early restoration of the chest wall integrity and respiratory pump function may be cost effective through the prevention of prolonged mechanical ventilation and restriction-related working incapacity.
Key Words: Chest trauma Flail chest Stabilisation Lung function testing
| 1. Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| 2. Patients and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
| 3. Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Associated hemothorax and pneumothorax were found in 62 patients (94%) and 57 patients (86%) on the chest X-ray at admission. CT scan revealed an associated lung contusion in 53 patients (80%). Twenty-three patients (35%) were intubated before or upon admission, due to respiratory insufficiency, associated cerebral injuries or hypovolemic shock. The flail chest was unilateral in 91% (60 of 66 patients) and bilateral in 9% of the patients (6 of 66 patients). The mean number of fractured ribs was 6, ranging from 4 to 11. Three patients presented with bilateral antero-lateral instability, which was stabilised through a transverse submammary approach. In three other patients presenting with bilateral flail chest, fixation of the chest wall was performed on the side with antero-lateral instability while the contralateral side with postero-lateral instability was treated conservatively. The median time from admission to stabilisation of the chest wall was 2.8 days (range 021 days). The mean operating time was 145 min, ranging from 60 to 200 min. Immediate postoperative extubation was feasible in 31 patients (47%). The median duration of postoperative intubation was 2.1 days, ranging from 0.5 to 26 days. The median hospital stay was 17.4 days, with a range of 860 days. Forty-six patients (70%) received continuous peridural analgesia for up to 10 days. The patients were transferred from the intensive care unit (ICU) to the ward after an average of 6.8 days (range 148 days). The overall 30-day mortality was 11% (7 of 66 patients). Four patients died of adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) and multiorgan failure, due to persistent pneumonia. These patients underwent delayed operative stabilisation, after mechanical ventilation for up to 3 weeks had failed to achieve adequate consolidation of the unstable chest wall. Two other patients died from cerebral haemorrhage and infarction, respectively, and one from refractory arrhythmia subsequent to a severe cardiac contusion. Postoperative complications were observed in 12 patients (18%). These included atelectasis and pneumonia of the ipsilateral lung in five, acalculous cholecystitis in three, myocardial infarction in two, and wound infection in two patients. All five patients with postoperative pneumonia recovered after treatment by bronchoscopy, mini-tracheotomy and antibiotics. Cholecystectomy was performed in the three patients with acalculous cholecystitis. The two patients with myocardial infarction underwent successful fibrinolysis. Two patients developed superficial wound infections 10 and 13 days after chest wall stabilisation, which required re-operation and wound debridement. In both cases, extended contusion of overlying soft tissues was found at the time of the initial operation. Removal of the plates and screws was not necessary and healing was achieved with drainage and antibiotics.
Six months follow-up was obtained in 57 of 59 surviving patients (97%) and revealed uneventful healing in all patients, including the two patients who had superficial wound infections. Attenuated sensitivity of the anterior chest wall was noted in four patients (7%). Six patients (11%) suffered from persistent pain in the operative site, which was improved in three patients following complete removal of all plates and screws. Shoulder girdle function was symmetrical in 51 patients (90%), whereas in six patients abduction of the ipsilateral shoulder was limited to 100°. These patients also had associated injuries of the ipsilateral shoulder girdle or brachial plexus. No chest wall deformity was observed in any patient. Radiological evaluation at follow-up showed no dislocation of plates in any of the patients, however, an asymptomatic dislocation of one and two screws was seen in two patients, respectively. All patients returned to work after a mean period of 8 weeks (range 316 weeks) following discharge. Pulmonary function testing 6 months following surgery was performed in 50 out of 57 surviving patients (88%). Pulmonary function revealed normal values in 26 patients (52%), an obstruction pattern in 11 (22%) and mixed obstruction and restriction in 8 (16%).
Based on the assumption that pulmonary restriction would be reflected by a TLC value of less than 85% of the predicted value, the ratio of the recorded and predicted TLC for all patients was calculated. By use of a non-parametric rank test, the ratio was shown to be significantly higher than 0.85 (P=0.0002) (Fig. 3 ). A restriction as defined as a recorded TLC less than 85% of the predicted value was found in five patients (10%). All five of these patients were working full-time without complaints.
|
| 4. Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Conservative therapy with aggressive chest physiotherapy (including bronchoscopy to aid the clearance of bronchial secretions) and optimal pain control is the mainstay of conventional therapy for flail chest [7]. If respiratory failure occurs, intubation and prolonged ventilation are often required [7]. Tracheotomy is often performed early to aid weaning and to prevent the tracheal complications of prolonged ventilation. Continuous epidural analgesia has proven to be beneficial for optimal pain control and can decrease both the duration of the ICU and overall hospital stay [8]. It has been shown to be superior to other forms of pain management in this situation [9].
In patients with cerebral injuries and extensive lung contusion, endotracheal intubation is mandatory [3]. The purpose of respiratory support in flail chest is to reduce atelectasis and the resulting shunt and to facilitate removal of secretions from the airways [5]. It can be performed with continuous positive airway pressure or with intermittent mandatory ventilation plus positive end-respiratory pressure. Furthermore, mechanical ventilation provides an internal pneumatic stabilisation of the flail chest until fibrous stabilisation is achieved. However, prolonged mechanical ventilation can be associated with a high prevalence of complications, including chest infection, septicaemia and barotrauma [10]. Gregoretti et al. [11] showed that ventilatory assistance via a mini-tracheotomy could reduce some of the side effects of prolonged tracheal intubation. Finally, Tzelepis et al. [12] showed that the distortion of the chest wall imposed by ventilators may increase the work of breathing and may actually contribute to difficulties in weaning the patient from the ventilator.
Chest wall stabilisation has been used to shorten the period of intubation in order to reduce the morbidity due to prolonged mechanical ventilation as well as the ICU stay in selected patients [5,10,13]. However, surgical management of flail chest is highly controversial. There are no prospective randomised trials comparing conservative and surgical management of flail chest. The goal of this prospective study was to analyse pulmonary lung function after surgical chest wall stabilisation and to determine if osteosynthesis reduces the incidence of residual restriction.
The first group of patients consisted of young patients with flail chest and severe chest wall dislocation. Despite peridural analgesia, pain control was difficult to achieve and the patients could not clear their secretions by coughing. Chest X-rays showed progressive chest wall shrinkage with reduction of the volume of the ipsilateral chest cavity. This has already been described as a valid indication for chest wall stabilisation [14]. Patients with antero-lateral dislocations are particularly prone to develop late restriction and pseudarthrosis leading to partial or complete professional incapacity.
Chest wall stabilisation was performed with standard 3.5 mm thick reconstruction plates as used for pelvic stabilisation. Numerous other types of implants have been advocated but none of them have provided reliable and durable stable osteosynthesis [13,15]. These plates have already been shown to be very efficient for chest wall stabilisation. They are long enough to cover a substantial length of the ribs and to allow a minimal anchorage of two (or ideally three) screws on either side of the fracture site. They can easily be conformed to the shape of the individual ribs in an ideal position, which is provided by expansion of the underlying lung during mechanical ventilation [4,5,16]. No dislocation of plates was observed in our series. The two patients with screw dislocation presented with severe osteoporosis and the screws had been placed antero-laterally within cartilage.
Lung contusion was observed on preoperative CT scans in 80% of the patients. It has been demonstrated that extensive lung contusion increases the incidence of pneumonia and the need for prolonged mechanical ventilation [17]. Therefore, extensive and slowly resolving contusion is a relative contraindication for flail chest stabilisation because these patients require prolonged intubation and will not benefit from the advantages of early chest wall stabilisation [18,19]. In our series, most of the patients had well less than 30% of non-functional lung tissue and could therefore be extubated early after chest wall stabilisation. Six patients who presented with an extensive lung contusion and flail chest were operated on secondarily because persistent paradoxical movements of the chest wall prevented weaning from the respirator.
The overall 30-day mortality was 11%. This compares favourably to reported mortality rates of 1530% [1]. Death in patients with flail chest is often due to pneumonia, sepsis and the development of an ARDS [20]. In our series, pneumonia progressing to ARDS in association with multiorgan failure was also a major cause of death. All four patients who died from ARDS were elderly patients who had prolonged intubation. They developed pneumonia with sepsis. Delayed chest wall stabilisation was performed but patients could still not be weaned from the ventilator. This would support the opinion that early chest wall stabilisation may be especially indicated in elderly patients with flail chest to prevent the complications of long-term mechanical ventilation [5,13].
Ten percent of the patients complained of residual chest wall discomfort at the 6-month follow-up visit. This was due either to chronic pain or to an impression of rigidity of the chest wall. It is difficult to determine to what extent this is due to the initial trauma of the soft tissues, muscles and chest wall or to the operation itself. It could be demonstrated in these patients that complaints were not related to functional impairment, since their pulmonary function was normal, i.e. without restriction. Our results suggest that chest wall stabilisation with reconstruction plates does not lead to impaired postoperative pulmonary function. However, Kishikawa et al. [21] observed that pulmonary function could fully recover within 6 months of injury in patients without extensive lung contusion despite a residual deformity of the chest wall caused by flail chest. Nonetheless, our results suggest that operative stabilisation in patients without major lung contusion may provide better cosmetic results and considerable savings due to a reduction on the use of ICU and general hospital resources as compared to conservative therapy in selected cases while preserving both pulmonary function and of the quality of life.
In conclusion, we think that surgical chest wall stabilisation has a place in the multimodality therapy of flail chest. The best indication for early operative chest wall stabilisation is the presence of antero-lateral flail chest and respiratory failure without severe pulmonary contusion, especially in the elderly. This can provide an important reduction in the duration of ventilatory support as well as the preservation of chest wall mechanics and lung function. Secondary stabilisation is recommended in patients with pulmonary contusion showing persistent instability of the chest wall, which prevents weaning from the ventilator. Finally non-intubated patients with deteriorating pulmonary function in the setting of a flail chest benefit from stabilisation in terms of respiratory dynamics, better clearance of secretions through efficient cough and improved pain control.
| Footnotes |
|---|
| Appendix A. Conference discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Dr Lardinois: No, we have operated about 10% of the patients with severe antero-lateral flail chest. Preoperative CT scan showed lung contusion in 80% of the patients, but most of these patients had less than 30% of non-functional lung tissue and could benefit from an early extubation. We have only operated 6 patients (9%) with extended lung contusion. In these patients, persistent paradoxical movements prevented weaning from the respirator and a prolonged intubation was mandatory.
Dr Wihlm (Strasbourg, France): First of all, you didn't indicate the causes of this flail chest etiology. The speed is limited in Switzerland. They are very strongly limited to 120 kilometers per hour on the motorways and the police are everywhere. I'm surprised that you have so many cases. Could you tell us if it's only traffic cases or whatever?
Dr Lardinois: 60.6% of the patients had motor vehicle accidents, about 30% of the patients were injured at work, and about 9% were injured during sports activities.
Dr Wihlm: How long has the series been? Is it a historic series?
Dr Lardinois: The study was performed during 10 years, from 1990 to 1999.
Dr Wihlm: What is the average time before the patient comes into the ICU and you operate on him? Did you operate immediately? What is the average time you are waiting on their ventilation?
Dr Lardinois: The median delay from admission to operation was 2.8 days. We have only stabilized two patients immediately after admission because a thoracotomy was mandatory, due to a massive hemothorax. Otherwise, the operation was performed as a deferred emergency in patients who did not require prolonged intubation but failed to wean. In the patients without intubation at admission, a peridural analgesia was usually performed. If the patients were unable to cough and to mobilise their secretions despite optimal analgesia or if a progressive shrinkage of the volume of the chest cavity was observed on successive chest X-rays, we proposed to operate these patients after a few days to prevent and to avoid pneumonia, especially in the elderly.
Dr Klepetko (Vienna, Austria): I just want to add a question on the indication for the stabilization. You have explained it for those patients who were not intubated. But for the other group, the patients who were already intubated, how do you judge in them? Do you try to go into some process of weaning, and, if you see that it doesn't work immediately, proceed with the operative procedure, or do you not do any attempts at all to wean the patients? In addition, does the number of ribs involved clearly have an impact on your judgment or not?
Dr Lardinois: In the patients intubated at admission, if a prolonged intubation for conditions such as cerebral injuries or extended lung contusion was not required, we always tried to wean these patients from the ventilator. A stabilization of the chest wall was performed only in the patients who failed to wean after 2 or 3 days to avoid complications of a prolonged intubation. The mean number of fractured ribs was 6, ranging from 4 to 11.
Dr Ris: As co-author, I would like to make a comment. We have presented a very selected patient group. Out of about 300 to 400 patients a year with serial rib fractures, there were maybe 50 patients with flail chest and only about 10 per year were stabilized by osteosynthesis. This technique has been reserved for severe flail chest, with completely unstable or impacted chest wall, and in fact in these patients we believe that operatic stabilization might be a good alternative in order to prevent a three-week period of intubation. Of course, we do not stabilize all flail chests, but only those with marked instability or impactation, usually localized antero-laterally. However, these patients do profit from operations since the other solution would be a three-week period of intubation. We have seen that even after three weeks intubation, not all of these chest walls were stable, depending on the degree of soft tissue damage.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
B. J. Bibas and R. A. Bibas Operative stabilization of flail chest using a prosthetic mesh and methylmethacrylate. Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., June 1, 2006; 29(6): 1064 - 1066. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Granetzny, M. Abd El-Aal, E. Emam, A. Shalaby, and A. Boseila Surgical versus conservative treatment of flail chest. Evaluation of the pulmonary status Interactive CardioVascular and Thoracic Surgery, December 1, 2005; 4(6): 583 - 587. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Borrelly and M. H. Aazami New insights into the pathophysiology of flail segment: the implications of anterior serratus muscle in parietal failure Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., November 1, 2005; 28(5): 742 - 749. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. Athanassiadi, M. Gerazounis, and N. Theakos Management of 150 flail chest injuries: analysis of risk factors affecting outcome Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., August 1, 2004; 26(2): 373 - 376. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |