|
|
||||||||
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2002;21:664-670
© 2002 Elsevier Science NL
a Division of General Thoracic Surgery, University Hospital, 3030 Bern, Switzerland
b Division of Neurology, University Hospital, 3030 Bern, Switzerland
Received 17 September 2001; received in revised form 30 December 2001; accepted 3 January 2002.
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +41-31-632-2330; fax: +41-31-632-2327
e-mail: ralph.schmid{at}insel.ch
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: Myasthenia gravis Thymectomy Transsternal
| 1. Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Most common symptoms are ptosis and diplopia in 65% of all patients, but only 10% of them stay with the ocular form of MG [2]. Mostly the disease gradually spreads to the skeletal muscles with weakness of the proximal girdle and the bulbar muscles with dysarthria, dysphagia and poor mastication. Generalized weakness and involvement of respiratory muscles are the final stage, which may lead to death without treatment in more than 29% of these patients [1].
MG is a disorder of the neuromuscular transmission leading to fatigue and weakness after repetitive use of voluntary muscles. The underlying autoimmune mechanism is the production of specific antibodies directed against the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) complex of the motor end-plate with functional impairment and numeric decrease of these receptors. The thymus, as the site of T-lymphocyte education with resulting self-tolerance, is thought to be an integral part in the pathogenesis of MG.
Thymectomy has been used to remove the main source of antibody production since the first operation for MG by Sauerbruch in 1911 [3]. After decades of transcervical operation Blalock established the transsternal approach in 1936 and demonstrated the favourable effect of the operation on the course of MG, with only six cases published in 1941 [3]. In 1942 Keynes published 200 transsternal thymectomies with a mortality of 33.5% for his first 20 patients. Since 1965 Akamura and Crile promoted the transcervical approach with certain advantages which were confirmed by Papatestas and Cooper. Masaoka developed the extended transsternal thymectomy in 1975 with good success.
Selection of patients and choice of ideal operation technique remains controversial, especially since introduction of minimally invasive approaches. Only few studies focus on long-term outcome after thymectomy for MG. The aim of the present study is to analyse long-term results with objective evaluation of efficacy and quality of life after a transsternal radical approach for MG patients and most importantly to compare short-term follow-up results with long-term outcome.
| 2. Patients and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2.2. Indications for surgery
Indications for surgery included new onset of generalized MG, failure of long-term conservative therapy (inclusively ocular form of MG, which is usually associated with a positive clinical provocation tests) or myasthenic symptoms with associated thymoma.
2.3. Operative technique
Median sternotomy is followed by opening the pleural space. The mediastinum is thoroughly explored up to the cervical thymic extension and laterally down to the phrenic nerves. All thymic tissue and the entire pericardial and mediastinal fat from the diaphragm to the thyroid is removed en bloc.
2.4. Analysis of the group
Prospective analysis of short-term follow-up was published in 1991 [4]. One patient of the original group (n=27) had a malignant thymoma without symptoms and was consequently excluded from further analysis. One patient with thymoma was initially classified into the wrong group. Except for these two changes the identical group of patients was re-evaluated with the same criteria by telephone interview and by written questionnaire in March 2001. Two patients were lost from follow-up (back in ex-Yugoslavia and in Libya, respectively) and one patient died 4 years after thymectomy of lung embolism.
Two patients with thymoma remained in the analysis and were not treated as a separate group.
One patient had already received a permanent tracheostoma 27 years before thymectomy and mediastinal irradiation.
2.5. Data analysis
Data were collected on actual symptoms, changes in health condition, hospitalizations, present medication and physician's care needed, local effect of surgery, effect of pregnancies, hormone treatments and other medication as well as capability to work and perform sports. Preoperative, postoperative, and short-term follow-up data were taken from the previous report.
For clinical assessment the actual severity of disease the classification of Osserman (Table 1) and Oosterhuis (Table 2) were applied by the same neurologist as in the study published 10 years ago.
|
|
2.7. Statistical analysis
We applied the McNemar Chi-square test to compare different stages of the same group over time. Univariate analysis with Fisher's test for evaluation of predictive factors was used. A P-value of lass than 0.05 was considered significant.
| 3. Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
3.2. Early morbidity and mortality
In the group of 23 patients no mortality was observed. All patients were extubated immediately after surgery; none needed tracheotomy.
Postoperative mean hospital stay including the period at the division of Neurology to stabilize MG was 9.4 days (range 723). One patient (4%) developed sternal osteomyelitis which needed intravenous antibiotic therapy and surgical debridement. We did not observe any other postoperative complications such as pneumonia or phrenic nerve palsy.
3.3. Late surgical complications
Two late reoperations were necessary: one for sternal wire removal after 1 year, and one re-exploration because of relapse of MG 9 years after the initial intervention for thymoma. Remnant thymic tissue was resected without clinical improvement (Osserman stage IIa).
Six patients (26%) had residual pain of the chest with only one needing medication. Two patients had minor sternal instability (9%) not requiring stabilization. Seven patients (30%) were noted to have hypertrophic scars but only one young woman was cosmetically disturbed. No patient considered correction of the scar.
3.4. Short-term results
At short-term follow-up (mean of 22.4 months, range 653) objective improvement in terms of Oosterhuis classification was observed in 17 patients (73.9%), including seven patients (30.4%) in complete remission. The accurate assessment was as follows: seven patients in stage 0 (30.4%), seven in stage 1 (30.4%), five in stage 2 (21.7%), three in stage 3 (13.2%) and one patient in stage 4 (4.3%); no patient was in stage 5 (Fig. 1) [4].
|
3.5. Late outcome
After 13.0 years of follow-up (range 11.415.2) six patients (26%) were in complete remission and objective improvements in terms of the Osserman classification was achieved in 13 patients (56.5%), P=0.0013 (Fig. 2)
.
|
|
Slight deterioration of the 2 years result (mean value: 1.48) was observed 13 years after thymectomy (mean value: 1.56), but the difference did not reach significance, P=0.405 (Fig. 1). This tendency was due to worsening of MG in eight patients (35%).
Twenty-two hospital admissions including five injuries were necessary for 15 patients in the course of a mean 13 years: five times due to aggravation of MG of which two with myasthenic crisis, three needing plasmapheresis and one intubation. No cholinergic crisis nor brittle myasthenia was observed. Two patients (8.7%) developed a malignant disease: lymphoma and cancer of the uterus, respectively.
At the time of assessment 11 patients (47.8%) do not take any myasthenic medication and two (9%) need reduced therapy. Eleven patients (48%) still require prostigmine and six (26%) immunosuppressive therapy alone or in combination (Fig. 4) .
|
In the univariate analysis factors such as age<40 years (n=12), duration of preoperative symptoms<1 year (n=10) and severe stage Osserman>IIb (n=11) did not significantly influence the outcome.
For complete remission no predictive factor could be detected. In contrast to other studies less severe initial disease (Osserman stage IIIa) resulted in better remission rates (42 vs. 9%).
All patients had an AChR antibody serology preoperatively done, of which only four (17%) were negative (three with Osserman stage I and one with stage IV). Preoperative presence of AChR antibody did not predict better outcome (50 vs. 58%).
3.7. Subjective evaluation and patients quality of life
Subjectively, 19 patients (82.6%) consider themselves to be in either very good condition (n=6), good condition (n=4) or better than before surgery (n=9). Three patients did not observe any change (13.1%) and one feels worse than before surgery (4.3%).
Fifteen patients (65.2%) are working full-time, of which four women are housekeeping. One patient (4.3%) worked full-time until his retirement. Three patients (13.1%) experienced progressive incapability to work and are actually retired. One patient (4.3%) is working at a reduced level because of MG and three (13.1%) are not able to work. Fourteen patients (61%) perform some kind of sport regularly.
Of six children born by three women, none showed any neonatal form of transmitted MG. Only one caesarean section was needed. Five women used oral contraceptives and never experienced any change of myasthenic symptoms.
No patient ever sensed any worsening of MG after taking different medication.
3.8. Histology
Histological examination of the thymus showed atrophy (n=7), normal thymus (n=6), lymphoid follicles (n=6), germinal centres (n=7), hyperplasia (n=2), and two thymoma stage I of Masaoka. Five times (22%) aberrant ectopic thymic tissue was found: four times in pericardial fat and once in the aorto-pulmonary window.
| 4. Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
To our knowledge no randomized study has ever been performed, neither between medical and surgical approach nor between different surgical procedures. The beneficial effect of thymectomy for MG is generally accepted and can be confirmed with the present study. The remission and improvement rate after surgery cannot be reached with conservative therapy, despite the fact that spontaneous remission may occur in 1114% [5]. It is often forgotten that the mortality rate of non-operated patients with MG was as high as 26% and has decreased dramatically after the introduction of early thymectomy [6]. Our series also confirms the safety of this operative procedure, with no postoperative mortality and a minimal number of early and late complications, and therefore underlines the importance of thymectomy as a cornerstone of the treatment of MG.
We can demonstrate that 57% of the patients have a significant objective improvement including 26% of the patients with complete remission (no symptoms nor medication for MG) after 13 years of follow-up.
Other much larger studies demonstrated this fact, but no study so far has such a long mean follow-up. The loss of 8% (2/26) of the patients after 13 years is very acceptable. In contrast to other series with long-term evaluation [7,8] we did not observe as many postoperative late remissions as expected from the literature, but a number of late relapses resulting in an overall slight decrease of improvement rate over the entire observation period. This finding indicates that every new technique has to be evaluated carefully and honestly for long-term results despite the advantages of the minimal invasive approach by either thoracoscopy [912] or transcervical procedure [1315] with better acceptance by patients and neurologists.
We still favour the transsternal radical approach at our centre, as we have detected extrathymic fat tissue in 22% of the patients. In the literature this rate is even as high as 39.5% [16]. It is known that only 4.5 g of remnant thymic tissue may lead to symptoms [17] and therefore radical thymectomy has been chosen to obtain maximal therapeutic benefit [18]. The transverse sternotomy advocated by some authors does not seem to ameliorate the results of the standard procedure [19]. The extended thymectomy does not result in a better remission rate (38%), perhaps because of ectopic thymic tissue (like thyroid or tonsil) [20].
Almost half of the patients in the present study (48%) currently do not need any myasthenic medication and in 9% the medication could be strongly reduced postoperatively. We did not observe clinically relevant complications due to immunosuppressive therapy, particularly conditions after long-term steroid therapy such as diabetes, hypertension, gastric ulcer, osteoporosis or infection.
Additionally it has been reported that, due to a reduced immunosuppressive regimen, the risk of developing malignant diseases can be reduced by 50% after thymectomy from 8 to 4% after 10 years observation [6]. In our series we observed two malignancies in 13 years. Surprisingly we did not observe associated immunological diseases such as, for example, Hashimoto thyroiditis which is reported to occur in 10% of patients with MG.
Indeed, 70% of the patients did not consult a specialist such as a neurologist or ophthalmologist for their disease, and 39% of all patients did not consult any physician at the time of the assessment.
In summary, the quality of life of the group of patients in this study is very good with nearly 90% of the patients back to work after surgery (including partial work) and two-thirds (65.2%) actually working full-time (including 17% at home). Regular sports such as walking, hiking, horse riding, cycling, swimming, skiing or shooting are performed by 61%. To improve cosmetic results we use a transverse curved skin incision for young women which will be completely covered under a bra. The relatively long postoperative stay at hospital in the 1980s cannot be compared with patient management nowadays.
Only female gender has been identified as a predictive factor in our study. Other often mentioned prognostic factors [19] such as age (<40 years), duration of preoperative symptoms (<1 year) and severity (stage Osserman>IIb) did not influence the outcome in a statistically significant way. This might be because of the small number of patients, as for example 75% of the patients under 40 years improved in contrast to 36% over 40 years (P=0.10).
Compared to previously published series [68,1014,1922], our results after 13 years of follow-up show similar results for complete remission with a rate of 26% (1147%). The improvement rate of 31% was lower than in published studies, ranging from 34 to 70% (Table 3). These results may be influenced by an unfavourable inverted gender distribution (male/female ratio 7:4) in combination with long preoperative duration of symptoms up to 29 years, as it is known that MG becomes fixed after more than 15 years in the course of disease (burn-out stage) [23].
Analyzing the improvement rates of different studies (Table 3) in correlation to observation time we note that improvement was becoming worse with duration of observation, although most individual studies paradoxically indicate improvement of outcome over time. In this respect a careful meta-analysis of these studies is needed.
We also noted that the complete remission rate of patients operated on by a video-assisted thoracoscopic approach was low [1012]. If the improvement rate is indeed declining over time, long-term studies after minimally invasive thymectomy might show surprising results.
In conclusion, the transsternal radical thymectomy remains the gold standard for thymectomy in MG patients. Two-thirds of the patients with a mean follow-up of 13 years lead a normal life with normal everyday activity including regular sports. Short-term results seem to predict long-term outcome, but careful review of the literature seems to indicate a deterioration of the initial results over time. Therefore, long-term studies for minimally invasive thymectomy are warranted to establish equal long-term results.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
E. Pompeo, F. Tacconi, R. Massa, D. Mineo, S. Nahmias, and T. C. Mineo Long-term outcome of thoracoscopic extended thymectomy for nonthymomatous myasthenia gravis Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., July 1, 2009; 36(1): 164 - 169. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. M. Ponseti, J. Gamez, R. Vilallonga, C. Ruiz, J. Azem, M. Lopez-Cano, and M. Armengol Influence of ectopic thymic tissue on clinical outcome following extended thymectomy in generalized seropositive nonthymomatous myasthenia gravis Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., November 1, 2008; 34(5): 1062 - 1067. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Chalabreysse, A. Orsini, C. Vial, and F. Tronc Microscopic thymoma Interactive CardioVascular and Thoracic Surgery, February 1, 2007; 6(1): 133 - 135. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. C. Roth and R. A. Schmid Reply to tellez-zenteno. Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., August 1, 2006; 30(2): 412 - 412. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. C. Roth, J. Raths, G. Carboni, K. Rosler, and R. A. Schmid Effect of pregnancy and birth on the course of myasthenia gravis before or after transsternal radical thymectomy Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., February 1, 2006; 29(2): 231 - 235. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. de Kraker, J. Kluin, N. Renken, A. P.W.M. Maat, and A. J.J.C. Bogers CT and myasthenia gravis: correlation between mediastinal imaging and histopathological findings Interactive CardioVascular and Thoracic Surgery, June 1, 2005; 4(3): 267 - 271. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. Ozdemir, M. Kara, E. Dikmen, A. Nadir, M. Akal, N. Yucemen, and S. Yavuzer Predictors of clinical outcome following extended thymectomy in myasthenia gravis Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., February 1, 2003; 23(2): 233 - 237. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |