|
|
||||||||
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2004;25:1089-1096
© 2004 Elsevier Science NL
Division of Thoracic Surgery, Policlinico Tor Vergata University, Rome, Italy
Received 20 October 2003; received in revised form 26 January 2004; accepted 28 January 2004.
* Corresponding author. Address: Policlinico Tor Vergata, Cattedra di Chirurgia Toracica, Università Tor Vergata, Viale Oxford 81, 00133 Rome, Italy. Tel.: +39-6-2090-2884; fax: +39-6-2090-2881
e-mail: mineo{at}med.uniroma2.it
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: Oesophagus Achalasia Oesophagomyotomy Fundoplication
| 1. Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Since the beginning of our experience on achalasia, we have added anterior partial fundoplication according to the Dor technique [8] in addition to Heller myotomy. We have gathered consistent data on patients followed for a long-term period.
The aim of this study is to analyse the long-term outcome of Heller myotomy and anterior fundoplication performed by the same surgeon as the first choice surgical treatment in patients with oesophageal achalasia. The results were evaluated according to objective and subjective measurements using validated quality of life (QOL) questionnaires for the latter.
| 2. Materials and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
3 cm (N=6); stage II, width between 3 and 6 cm (N=20); stage III, width >6 cm (N=2); stage IV, width >6 cm and sigmoid-shaped oesophagus (N=11). Dysphagia, regurgitation, chest pain and heartburn were classified preoperatively and postoperatively into four grades: grade 1=no symptoms; grade 2=mild symptoms occurring less than once weekly; grade 3=moderate symptoms occurring more than once weekly but not every day; grade 4=severe and persistent symptoms. The patients' satisfaction with the operation was assessed by asking them to choose one of the five possible responses: none=1, poor=2, medium=3, much=4, total=5.
In addition, since 1995, QOL was pre- and postoperatively assessed in all patients by means of the Nottingham Health Profile (NHP) [9] and Short-Form-36-Items (SF-36) [10]. We chose these questionnaires because both of them provide a good compromise between simplicity and sensitiveness in detecting QOL variations in emphysematous patients. Furthermore, both are available in validated versions for the Italian population.
The NHP is a short, easily administered questionnaire [9], which contains 38 questions relating to eight domains: mobility, energy, pain, social isolation, sleep disturbance, and emotional reactions. Individuals are asked to indicate perceived health status by ticking either yes or no after each question. Final score is indicated as a percentage related to the number of positive answer: all negative answers=0 (i.e. high QOL), all positive answers=100 (i.e. low QOL). Scores for each of the six topics are computed by summing weighted values given to each positive response. The SF-36 [10] consists of 36 questions that cover eight health concepts. Individuals are asked to indicate the most appropriate answer among a multiple-choice questionnaire. The evaluation included eight components: physical functioning, social functioning, physical role, emotional role, vitality, bodily pain, mental health, and general health perception. Both QOL tests were re-proposed to the patients yearly.
2.1. Surgical Technique
In the present study group the procedure was performed through a xiphoumbilical laparotomy incision. Laparoscopic procedures, which now represent the first choice approach in our department, were anyway excluded from the study due to the lack of long-term results for a consistent sample size. After visualization of the oesophagogastric junction, the phrenoesophageal membrane was incised anterolaterally using a cautery and only the anterior aspects of the oesophagus were separated bluntly from the diaphragmatic crura. The vagus nerves were identified.
Oesophageal dissection was completed in the mediastinum 56 cm above the oesophagogastric junction by pulling the lower oesophagus through the hiatus. Oesophageal myotomy was carried out on the central-left anterior wall of the oesophagus, starting from the midpoint and completing muscle dissection 6 cm upwards and at least 3 cm downwards onto the stomach. During oesophageal myotomy the longitudinal and circular fibres were divided by using cautery and scissors. An anterior Dor fundoplication was then performed suturing the anterior wall of the gastric fundus to the edges of the myotomy with three non-absorbable stitches on each side, with the upper stitch including the diaphragmatic crus. A nasogastric tube was left in the stomach.
2.2. Statistical analysis
Group descriptive statistics are presented as the mean±SD. The Wilcoxon or the MannWhitney tests were used for paired and unpaired data, respectively. Internal consistency of the two questionnaires was evaluated for groups and for global scores and specific domains by the Alpha Cronbach's test: the highest score possible for consistency was considered to be equal to 1 and the lowest equal to 0. Symptom-free survival analysis was assessed by the KaplanMeier method. Significance was set at P<0.05. Statistical analysis was carried out by the Statistica® software. To determine if improvement in QOL was correlated with swallowing function, we performed the non-parametric Spearman's correlation of the percentage change in individual parameters of oesophageal function and percentage change in QOL domains.
| 3. Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Oesophageal pH manometry was repeated yearly for the first 5 years and data were available in 33 patients. None showed significant reflux even in the presence of symptoms. Lower oesophageal sphincter pressure decreased significantly from 33±10 to 19.1±5.9 mmHg at 1 year. Postoperative pressure decrement was significant at all stages, but although greater in the advanced stages it was not correlated with the stage. Mild and non-significant increments were recorded at 5 years (20.3±5.7) and correlated with dysphagia (
=0.66, P=0.001) and regurgitation (
=0.40, P=0.04) scores. At 5 years as many as 16 patients presented pressure lower than 20 mmHg. In the nine patients assessed at 10 years, pressure was still significantly lower (23.4±6.7, P<0.001) than the basal value.
Oesophagoscopy was routinely performed postoperatively at 1 year even in the absence of symptoms. Afterwards, oesophagoscopy was performed yearly in all patients at stage III or IV and in the presence of heartburn. Grade I oesophagitis (according to SavaryMiller) was diagnosed in three symptomatic patients at 9, 13 and 33 months belonging to stage III, IV and I, respectively. In these patients gastro-oesophageal reflux was confirmed by 24-h pH-metry.
We carried out multiple biopsies of the oesophageal mucosa in only 10 patients at stage III and IV after a mean of 26 months; only one showed mild squamous dysplasia. No patient eventually required oesophagectomy or developed oesophageal carcinoma.
3.2. Subjective assessment
Mean dysphagia score assessed at 1 year decreased significantly from 3.6±0.5 to 1.3±0.7 and remained stable at 5 and 10 years; regurgitation showed the same trend (Table 2). Radiological stage IV presented the worst mean values, although they were not significant.
Four patients re-presented with dysphagia at 48 months for the patient at stage III, 56 months at stage IV, 71 months at stage II and 88 months at stage I. In the last three the discomfort was as intense as preoperatively. Two were re-operated (I and II stage) and one underwent periodical dilations (III). The patient at stage IV was satisfied and refused any further procedure. We were able to dismount the Dor plasty in the two re-operated patients and redo it. All these patients are well at 34 and 16 months after the second procedure. According to the re-operative findings the reason for failure was attributed to progressive inflammatory stricture.
Chest pain and heartburn mean scores did not significantly increase. Significant heartburn appeared in the three above-mentioned patients with endoscopic evidence of grade 1 oesophagitis, which was satisfactorily treated with proton-pump inhibitors. Fig. 1 shows the KaplanMeier curve for dysphagia relapse and heartburn development with a different pattern characterized by the earlier onset of the latter.
|
3.3. Quality of life assessment
Analysis was possible in 20 subjects for a 4-year period; in the earlier period of the study, questionnaires were not available. Internal consistency was higher for general NHP scores at 1 and 4 years (0.910.92) than SF-36 (0.840.88); also the rate of answered questions was higher for NHP (95%) than SF-36 (88%). Consistency at 1 year was similar to that at 4 years. In both questionnaires physical domains presented a higher consistency than psychosocial ones.
Baseline NHP and SF-36 domains scores are reported in Table 3. Fig. 2 shows a greater impairment of the psychosocial domains than physical ones when matched with a large sample size population of the same age. At postoperative assessment both physical and mainly psychosocial domains improved (data not shown) and remained stable up to 4 years, approximating values scored by a normal population of the same age. In NHP domains a significant long-lasting improvement was found in energy (P<0.01), social isolation (P<0.001) and emotional reactions (P<0.01). Also in many SF-36 domains we observed a significant 4-year improvement: general health (P<0.01), social function (P<0.001), vitality (P<0.001), mental health (P<0.01), physical role (P<0.05), and emotional role (P<0.05).
|
|
Four-year postoperative dysphagia score was inversely correlated with postoperative changes in social isolation (
=0.41, P=0.04), physical role (
=0.42, P=0.04) and mental health (
=0.45, P=0.02) domains, while postoperative lower oesophageal sphincter pressure was inversely correlated with changes in social isolation (
=0.40, P=0.04), emotional reactions (
=0.43, P=0.03), physical role (
=0.52, P=0.01), emotional role (
=0.42, P=0.03) and mental health (
=0.52, P=0.01).
| 4. Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In our opinion, partial fundoplication can prevent reflux after myotomy. This procedure represents a good compromise between the need to prevent otherwise inevitable reflux without re-creating an obstacle too important for an aperistaltic oesophagus. We have experience with the Dor procedure that we associate with an extended myotomy with good long-term results.
The difficulty in evaluating the effectiveness of each surgical technique depends also on the subjective criteria of evaluation and mix of symptoms not always correlated with dysphagia or with reflux [16]. Objective data (i.e. oesophagus size and manometry pressure of lower oesophageal sphincter) may largely change from one patient to another and can be difficult to interpret.
The advent of QOL questionnaires gave a more reliable and comparable outcome assessment measure. To our knowledge, this is the first time that NHP has been used to assess QOL in oesophageal achalasia. On the contrary, the SF-36 questionnaire has recently been used in some small surgical series [17,2123]. Ben-Meir and colleagues [21] evaluated 19 patients 21 months after surgery and found that physical function, bodily pain, vitality, and social function were significantly improved. Luketich and colleagues [22] studied 53 patients and found that after myotomy, all eight domains of SF-36 data scored at least equal or better than the normal US population used for comparison. However, in this series, no preoperative data were available for pre- to postoperative comparisons. These results were analogous with those obtained by Ponce et al. [17] in 28 Spanish-speaking patients who underwent open Heller myotomy plus Dor fundoplication. Katilius et al. [23] studied 15 patients after laparoscopic and eight after laparotomy myotomy. The SF-36 general health domain improved significantly in both groups although best scores in physical function and bodily pain were achieved following laparoscopic myotomy. Postoperative QOL assessment revealed no difference with the general population. Our findings support the use of the SF-36 as a reliable instrument for QOL assessment in achalasia patients. We have found greater postoperative improvements in the domains such as role limitations due to physical problems and social function. Correlation with degree of dysphagia and pressure of lower oesophageal sphincter seems not surprising since the existence of symptoms and signs leading to modification of eating habits has also been shown to impair QOL in other benign oesophageal diseases [24].
Findings recently reported by Decker et al. [25] demonstrating significant improvements in a specific gastrointestinal QOL questionnaire (not yet available in Italian validated translation) in patients with early and advanced stage achalasia seem in accordance with ours.
We acknowledge some limitations of our study: sample size, incomplete QOL score, long time-frame, but all these difficulties arise from the relative rarity of the disease and the difficulty in gathering a greater number of patients. One supplementary bias might be represented by the difficulty in assessing objectively reflux on the basis of symptoms, pH-manometry and oesophagoscopy; periodic routine 24-h pH-metry was introduced in 2001, thus long-term data for the study population are unavailable.
On the contrary, the merits of the study can be represented by the introduction of a QOL questionnaire never used in this disease and by the homogeneous technique in selection, operating procedure and follow up of the patients.
In this study, the Heller myotomy coupled with Dor fundoplication proved highly effective in improving objective measures, subjective symptoms and QOL especially in psychosocial domains in patients with any stage of achalasic oesophagus. Such results can also be observed in the long-term thus leading to the conclusion that Heller myotomy should be considered as a first choice treatment option for oesophageal achalasia.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
| Appendix A. Conference discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Dr Ambrogi: Yes, we have, but this is part of another study we are trying to set up. I didn't understand the questionnaire you use. Do you use the Gastrointestinal Quality of Life?
Dr Decker: Yes.
Dr Ambrogi: Unfortunately, we have this questionnaire, but unfortunately there is not a validated version for Italian-speaking people.
Dr Decker: I don't know for Italian, but there is a validated questionnaire for many other languages, Dutch, English, German and so on.
Dr Ambrogi: Of course.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. R. Lopushinsky and D. R. Urbach Pneumatic dilatation and surgical myotomy for achalasia. JAMA, November 8, 2006; 296(18): 2227 - 2233. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |